Friday, November 11, 2011

Debating Values and value criterion

Millitary conscription is unjust
Value: Justice
Criterion: Its not fair for certain people to go to war.
               Everybody doesnot want to go to war.
               Certain people are not prepared for war.

Mine is better because it explains why its not fair.
It shows the actual philosophy of the United States.
Justice is the best value to prove this.

Attack: It doesnt explain why its not fair it just states thaat
             The philosophy is "Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of happiness"
             Actually Peace is better because if you draft random people they might rise against the government and riot.

No comments:

Post a Comment